In mathematics, the word “trivial” pops up quite often, but its meaning isn’t always immediately obvious, especially if you’re just starting your mathematical journey. Understanding what mathematicians mean by “trivial” is crucial for interpreting mathematical texts and discussions correctly. It can refer to a few different situations, and grasping these nuances will significantly improve your comprehension of mathematical concepts.
Different Interpretations of “Trivial” in Mathematics
The most common use of “trivial” in math signifies something that is canonically obvious or uninteresting because it follows directly and easily from definitions or basic principles. Think of it as the mathematical equivalent of “no-brainer.” Here are a few examples to illustrate this point:
-
Trivial Maps: In various mathematical contexts, particularly in algebra and topology, a “trivial map” usually refers to the simplest possible function between two sets. For example, a trivial map might send every element of a set to a single, fixed element in another set, like mapping everything to 0, 1, or the identity element, depending on the context.
Alt text: Diagram illustrating a trivial map where all elements from set A are mapped to a single element in set B, highlighting the concept of a basic and uncomplicated function in mathematics.
-
Trivial Solutions: When solving equations, especially in number theory, “trivial solutions” are the solutions that are immediately apparent and don’t offer much new insight. A classic example is Fermat’s Last Theorem, $x^n+y^n=z^n$. The trivial solutions are cases like $x=y=z=0$, or when one of the variables is zero and the other two are equal to 1 (e.g., $x=z=1$ and $y=0$). These solutions are easy to spot but don’t reveal the deeper mathematical structure of the equation.
Alt text: Image representing Fermat’s Last Theorem equation, emphasizing the concept of trivial solutions as the obvious and less mathematically interesting answers to the equation.
-
Trivial Subgroups: In group theory, “trivial subgroups” of any group are always the group itself and the subgroup containing only the identity element. These subgroups exist for every group and are considered “trivial” because their existence is guaranteed by the definition of a group and subgroup, rather than being special or unique to a particular group.
Alt text: Diagram of a subgroup lattice, illustrating that trivial subgroups, such as the whole group and the identity subgroup, are fundamental and universally present in group theory.
“Trivial” as an Indicator of Assumed Obviousness
Sometimes, when a mathematician labels something as “trivial,” it means they believe that the fact is easily deducible from what has already been established or is considered common knowledge within the specific mathematical context. In this case, the author is choosing not to elaborate on a point they deem straightforward for their intended audience.
However, it’s important to recognize that what is “trivial” to an expert might not be trivial to someone less experienced in that area. This is a crucial point to consider when reading mathematical texts.
The Cautionary Tale of “Trivial”
While mathematicians use “trivial” to streamline explanations and avoid belaboring obvious points, it can sometimes be problematic. For a reader who doesn’t find something “trivial,” it can be discouraging or confusing. It’s a good practice for anyone writing mathematics (including students doing homework!) to be cautious when using “trivial,” “obvious,” or “clear.”
As the joke illustrates, even for experts, what seems “trivial” might require a moment of verification. A good rule of thumb is that if a step is truly trivial for your intended audience, you can simply state the result without explicitly calling it trivial. If there’s any chance of ambiguity or confusion, it’s always better to provide a brief explanation instead of relying on the word “trivial.”
In conclusion, “trivial” in math can mean canonically obvious, assumed to be obvious by the author, or sometimes even used as a bluff. As a reader, if you encounter something labeled “trivial” that isn’t immediately clear to you, don’t be discouraged. Take it as an opportunity to delve deeper and solidify your understanding. And as a writer, use “trivial” sparingly and consider the perspective of your audience to ensure clarity and effective communication.
