What is Communism? Exploring the Ideology of a Classless Society

Communism stands as a significant political and economic ideology aiming for a societal transformation. At its core, communism advocates for the elimination of private property and the establishment of public ownership over the primary means of production and natural resources. This system envisions a society where profit-driven economies are replaced by communal control and equitable distribution of wealth. Often considered a radical form of socialism, communism, in its ideal state, strives for a classless society devoid of government and economic inequality. The foundational principles of modern communism are deeply rooted in the theories of Karl Marx, a 19th-century German philosopher and revolutionary thinker.

Defining Communism: Core Principles and Ideals

Communism, in theory, proposes a societal structure starkly different from capitalism. It’s built upon several key tenets:

Public Ownership: The central principle of communism is the collective ownership of the means of production. This includes factories, land, resources, and infrastructure, all managed for the benefit of the community rather than private profit.
Classless Society: Communism aims to abolish social class distinctions. By eliminating private property, it seeks to remove the economic basis of class divisions, creating a society where everyone is equal.
Stateless Society (in theory): In its ultimate form, communism envisions a stateless society. The state, seen as a tool of class oppression, would become unnecessary as class divisions disappear. Resources and production would be managed communally without the need for government.
Distribution Based on Need: A core communist principle is “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs.” This means individuals contribute to society based on their capabilities, and in return, receive what they need to live and thrive.
Abolition of Private Property: Private ownership of property, particularly property used for production, is to be eliminated. Personal possessions might exist, but the means of creating wealth are collectively owned.

These principles, articulated most famously by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in The Communist Manifesto (1848), present a vision of a society fundamentally different from those based on capitalist principles.

Historical Roots of Communist Thought

While the term “communism” gained prominence in the 19th century, the concept of communal living and shared resources has roots stretching back to ancient times. Ideas that resonate with communist ideals can be found throughout history:

Ancient Philosophy: Plato, in his Republic, described an ideal society where the ruling class, the guardians, lived communally, holding property and even families in common to prevent corruption and self-interest.
Early Christianity: The early Christian communities, as depicted in the Book of Acts, practiced a form of communal living, sharing possessions and resources among believers. This is often cited as an early example of rudimentary communist principles in practice, driven by religious and ethical motivations.
Utopian Socialism: Thinkers like Sir Thomas More, in his book Utopia (1516), envisioned imaginary societies where private property was abolished, and resources were shared. These utopian visions explored the potential for more equitable and communal social structures.

However, modern communism, as a developed political and economic ideology, is primarily associated with the response to the Industrial Revolution and the work of Karl Marx.

Marxist Communism: A Scientific Approach

Karl Marx, along with Friedrich Engels, transformed earlier notions of communism into a comprehensive and purportedly “scientific” theory. Marxism, the body of thought developed by Marx and Engels, provided a framework for understanding history, society, and economics that led to the advocacy of communism. Key aspects of Marxist communism include:

Historical Materialism: Marx argued that history is driven by material conditions and class struggle. Societies evolve through different stages, each characterized by specific modes of production and class relations.
Class Struggle: Marxist theory posits that history is essentially a history of class struggles. In capitalist society, the primary struggle is between the bourgeoisie (the capitalist class who own the means of production) and the proletariat (the working class who sell their labor).
Critique of Capitalism: Marx saw capitalism as inherently exploitative. He argued that capitalists extract surplus value from the labor of workers, leading to inequality and alienation.
Revolution and the Dictatorship of the Proletariat: Marx believed that the inherent contradictions of capitalism would lead to its eventual overthrow by the proletariat in a socialist revolution. This revolution would establish a “dictatorship of the proletariat,” a transitional state where the working class controls the state and economy.
Two Phases of Communism: Marx outlined two phases of communist society. The first phase, often equated with socialism, is a transitional stage where the state still exists, and distribution might be based on work. The second, higher phase is full communism – a stateless, classless society with distribution based on need.

Vladimir Lenin, a prominent Russian revolutionary, further developed Marxist theory, particularly focusing on the practical aspects of revolution and the role of a vanguard party in leading the proletariat. Leninism adapted Marxism to the context of early 20th-century Russia and became a significant influence on communist movements worldwide.

Communism in Practice: The 20th Century and Beyond

The 20th century witnessed the rise of communist states in various parts of the world, most notably in the Soviet Union, China, and other nations. These states, while claiming to be based on Marxist-Leninist principles, often deviated significantly from the theoretical ideals of communism:

The Soviet Union: The Bolshevik Revolution of 1917 led to the establishment of the Soviet Union, the first major state identifying as communist. However, instead of a stateless, classless society, the Soviet Union developed into a one-party state with a powerful bureaucracy and a centrally planned economy.
Command Economies: Communist states typically implemented command economies, where the state controlled production, distribution, and pricing. While intended to eliminate capitalist exploitation and ensure equitable distribution, these economies often suffered from inefficiency, shortages, and lack of innovation.
Authoritarianism: In practice, communist states were characterized by authoritarian rule, suppression of dissent, and limited individual freedoms. The “dictatorship of the proletariat” often morphed into the dictatorship of a single party and its leaders.
The Collapse of the Soviet Union: The late 20th century saw the decline and eventual collapse of the Soviet Union and communist regimes in Eastern Europe. Economic stagnation, popular discontent, and internal pressures contributed to this collapse, demonstrating the challenges of implementing communist systems in the real world.
Contemporary Communist States: Today, a few countries officially identify as communist, including China, Vietnam, Cuba, Laos, and North Korea. However, these countries exhibit significant variations in their economic and political systems. Many have incorporated market mechanisms into their economies while maintaining one-party rule.

Britannica Premium Banner

Communism vs. Socialism: Distinguishing the Terms

The terms “communism” and “socialism” are often used interchangeably, but there are key distinctions, particularly in their historical and theoretical context.

Marx’s Usage: Karl Marx himself often used “communism” and “socialism” synonymously, especially in his earlier writings.
Lenin’s Distinction: Vladimir Lenin and later communist theorists drew a distinction between socialism and communism, viewing socialism as the first, lower stage of communism. In this view, socialism is the transitional phase after capitalism, still retaining some elements of state and even market mechanisms, while communism is the higher, ultimate stage – a stateless, classless society.
Practical Usage: In contemporary usage, “socialism” often refers to a broader range of ideologies and systems that aim to reduce inequality and increase social welfare within a democratic framework, often through state intervention and regulation of the economy, but not necessarily abolishing private property entirely. “Communism” remains more specifically associated with the Marxist-Leninist tradition and the historical experiences of 20th-century communist states.

In essence, while both ideologies share a critique of capitalism and a desire for greater social and economic equality, communism, particularly in its Marxist-Leninist interpretation, envisions a more radical transformation of society, aiming for a complete abolition of private property, class distinctions, and ultimately, the state itself.

Conclusion: The Enduring Idea of Communism

Communism, as an ideology, has profoundly impacted the 20th century and continues to be a relevant topic of discussion and debate. While the practical implementations of communism in the 20th century faced significant challenges and contradictions, often deviating from its core ideals, the underlying vision of a classless, egalitarian society continues to resonate. Understanding communism requires grappling with its theoretical foundations, its historical manifestations, and its ongoing evolution in the 21st century.