Rent control is a government regulation that restricts the amount a landlord can charge for renting a property or renewing a lease. These laws, typically enacted at the municipal level, aim to ensure affordable housing for lower-income residents. The specifics of rent control vary significantly across different jurisdictions.
As of 2024, rent control isn’t widely implemented across the United States. Approximately 305 municipalities have rent control regulations. The states with rent control policies at either the state or local level include California, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, and Washington D.C.
Conversely, 33 states have preemptive laws prohibiting local governments from establishing rent control measures.
The concept of rent regulation has seen a resurgence in recent years, particularly in areas facing a combination of soaring living costs and stagnant wages, leading to a housing affordability crisis for moderate-income residents and older adults on fixed incomes.
Oregon made history as the first U.S. state to implement a statewide rent control law. This law, enacted in March 2019, caps annual rent increases at 7% plus the increase in the Consumer Price Index (CPI).
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/GettyImages-1392911247-e7441600a8024911a56c09070231a881.jpg)
Image: A modern apartment building illustrating the type of housing potentially subject to rent control policies.
How Rent Control Operates
The earliest forms of rent control in the U.S. emerged in the 1920s, often as outright rent freezes. These proved largely unsustainable. The concept resurfaced in the 1970s, evolving into a more moderate approach often referred to as “rent stabilization.”
New York City, for instance, has two distinct rent control programs:
- Rent Control (Older Program): This program, gradually being phased out, imposed strict limitations on rental prices. However, it now applies only to tenants who have resided since 1974 or earlier in buildings constructed before 1947.
- Rent Stabilization (1970s-Era Program): This program regulates prices in approximately half of the city’s rental units. Rent increases are permitted only for one- or two-year terms, with allowable percentage increases determined by the Rent Guidelines Board, whose nine members are appointed by the mayor. The rules are intricate and administered by a combination of city and state agencies.
The high cost of living in New York City is often cited as evidence against the effectiveness of rent control. As of January 2025, the average rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Manhattan was $5,332 for a doorman building and $3,709 for a non-doorman building.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Rent Control
Rent control has consistently been a contentious issue. Current regulations primarily focus on regulating price increases for lease renewals, rather than setting initial rents for new tenants. This can provide some benefits for landlords, who can charge market rates on vacant units.
The primary arguments against rent control include:
- Reduced Housing Supply: Landlords may choose to convert buildings into condominiums or repurpose them for commercial use rather than comply with rent control laws, which limits their profitability.
- Discouraged Investment: Construction of new rental housing significantly declines.
- Neglected Maintenance: Landlords may reduce or eliminate building maintenance due to lower returns on investment.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/GettyImages-182896433-e4b0f57790024056a887924348536d19.jpg)
Image: A view of residential apartments in New York City, where rent control policies are prevalent and debated.
The main arguments in favor of rent regulation include:
- Rapidly Rising Rents: Rental prices in many U.S. cities are increasing much faster than wages for moderate-income jobs.
- Affordable Living: Rent control may enable moderate-income families and individuals on fixed incomes to maintain a decent standard of living without the threat of significant rent increases.
- Neighborhood Stability: Neighborhoods can become safer and more stable with a consistent base of long-term residents in rent-controlled apartments.
Advocates of rent control, such as the Urban Institute, contend that these price controls enable moderate-income residents and elderly individuals on fixed incomes to remain in their homes as gentrification pushes prices higher.
Understanding Rent-Controlled Apartments
A rent-controlled apartment is one where the rent amount is limited by a government program. These limits are established by local municipalities, and not all states or cities have such regulations. When rent is “controlled,” landlords cannot unfairly increase the price from year to year, potentially making housing more affordable for those who cannot afford market or above-market rates. The limitations can protect tenants from drastic increases.
How to Find a Rent-Controlled Apartment
In most cases, particularly in New York City, accessing a rent-controlled apartment is challenging unless you inherit the lease from a family member. These apartments are generally not available to the public, and the rules governing lease succession can be complex.
Determining if Your Apartment is Rent Controlled
Generally, if you reside in a rent-controlled apartment, it would have been passed down within your immediate or extended family, indicating its rent-controlled status. Reviewing your lease agreement and contacting your local housing authority can also help determine your apartment’s status.
Conclusion: The Ongoing Debate of Rent Control
Rent control remains a contentious yet vital mechanism for preserving affordable housing in high-cost areas. While it offers protection to low- and moderate-income renters from sudden rent hikes, critics argue that it can lead to housing shortages and property neglect. Rent stabilization laws, such as those in New York City, attempt to strike a balance between tenant protection and market realities, although their effectiveness continues to be debated. With rising rents and an escalating affordability crisis, the discussion surrounding rent control is more pertinent than ever, especially in states and cities struggling with gentrification and income inequality.
